As a newish teacher, I am still trying to figure out where I stand on it. I do agree that giving "busy" work as homework is bad/lazy/ineffective teaching. I want all the work my students do to be meaningful; I just don't know if homework can be meaningful.
First, doesn't it always seem that the students who need to do the homework are the ones who don't do it? Also, do you grade it for correctness or for competition? And then I think, kids deal with so much at home, should I add to the stress? I'm still on the fence, but I better figure it out soon... School starts in three weeks!
Where do you stand on homework? Does it work for you and your class?